The Lattice
No design can guarantee a good future. The best that a design can do is to make errors cheap to find and cheap to correct. Every rule on this page uses that test.
One small Compact repeats at every level, from a state to a nation to a global league. Pick a scale. The words change, and the rules stay.
Messages cross the planet in under a second. The limit is oversight: a capital cannot see local facts well, and help can take days to arrive.
The Map
Pick a mode, an attack, an article, or an organ. The map shows who holds power, who defends, and where the attack lands.
Nation · the same template at every level
States · hold every power not given up
The Compact
We, the people of the states, make this Compact so that no person rules by birth, no group rules by force or money, and the people can correct every error without blood.
-
I Core
No Rule by Birth
All persons have equal rights under this Compact. No office, seat, or public power passes by birth. No law can create a caste, and no person can own another person.
-
II Core
The Floor
Every person has a right to the air, water, power, food, and shelter that life needs. No authority can reduce them as a sanction or as a weapon. Every settlement keeps its life-support systems with backups that no single holder controls.
-
III Core
Departure
Every person can leave any state. When a person cannot pay for the passage, the nation pays.
-
IV Core
Speech and Truth
Every person can speak and publish. All money for political messages is public, with its source. The Audit publishes the public data that decisions use, in a form that any person can check.
-
V
Levels
Each decision stays at the lowest level that can make it well. A higher level holds only the powers that this Compact gives to it. Each level has the same four organs: a Council, an Executive, a Court, and an Audit.
-
VI
The Council
Seats come from every state, in proportion to population, with a minimum for each state. The states elect half of the seats, and a lot draws the other half from the citizens. No family holds more than one seat on any body. Each member serves one term of six years, and one third of the seats change every two years. The Council makes law, controls the purse and logistics command, and grants modes. It can remove the Executive by a two-thirds vote, at any time, without a reason.
-
VII
The Executive
A jury drawn by lot from all states meets in isolation. It selects the Executive from qualified candidates by a two-thirds approval vote, and the Council confirms the selection. The Executive serves one term of six years and cannot serve again. The Council, a citizen recall, or the Court (for a breach of this Compact) can remove the Executive.
-
VIII
The Court
The Court voids any act that breaks this Compact, including any act in any mode. A jury drawn by lot selects judges from qualified jurists, and the Council confirms them. Judges serve one term of twelve years, and cases go to judges by lot. The Court hears disputes between states.
-
IX
Force
Soldiers swear to this Compact, not to a person. The nation pays each soldier directly. Combat command reports to the Executive, and logistics command reports to the Council. Commanders rotate on a fixed schedule. No single person can order a strike on a populated place: that order needs two keys from two organs.
-
X
The Commons
Critical resources, routes, and shared channels, such as fresh water or grid power, are licensed, not owned. No holder can control more than one quarter of a critical supply in the nation. A share of the license revenue goes to every citizen as a dividend. Logistics command holds a strategic reserve.
-
XI
Modes
The law must define each mode before its use: who starts it, who holds which powers, the time limit, and who ends it. The Executive cannot start war mode or extend it. Each renewal of war mode needs more consent than the last. No mode can suspend the Council, the Court, the Audit, elections, the removal paths, or Articles I to IV.
-
XII
Exit and Distance
A state can leave the nation after two votes of two-thirds of its citizens, at least five years apart, and after a fair division of shared debts and assets. A new settlement carries this Compact. The control of a sponsor ends on a fixed date or when the settlement can supply itself, whichever is first. A sponsor cannot keep settlers by false information. When distance makes central action too slow, a group of states governs itself as its own union and joins the global league. The global league keeps this Compact and a Court, but no executive and no armed force.
-
XIII
Machines
Automated systems can advise, measure, and execute decisions. They cannot hold an office or release a weapon. The Audit can inspect any system that makes a public decision.
-
XIV
Renewal
A Review Convention, drawn by lot, meets every 30 years and can propose amendments. An amendment needs two-thirds of the Council and a majority of citizens in two-thirds of the states. Articles I to IV can grow, but no amendment can reduce them.
First Principles
-
01
Correct Errors Cheaply
Every ruler makes errors, and some rulers will be hostile. So the system must find and correct errors at low cost. The selection of good rulers is less important.
-
02
Separate the Levers
Power attracts people who want more power, and each concentration of power is a target. So no organ holds two of these levers: law, money, force, judgment, truth, and selection. An attacker must capture several independent organs, not one.
-
03
Distance Limits Command
Messages cross the planet in under a second. The limit is oversight: a capital cannot see local facts well, and help can take days to arrive. So each decision stays at the lowest level that can make it well.
-
04
Attack Is Cheaper Than Defense
As technology grows, one actor can destroy more. So weapons of mass destruction need two keys, and force depends on a supply that a different organ controls.
-
05
Life Support Is Political
The person who controls water, power, food, or air can force anyone to obey. So the means of life are a right, and no authority can use them as a sanction.
-
06
Protect Exit, Strengthen Voice
Exit is expensive for people and cheap for capital. Where exit is expensive, voice must be strong. Where exit is possible, the system must protect it.
-
07
Chokepoints Make Extractive Rulers
Whoever holds a chokepoint resource, such as fresh water or grid power, can extract from everyone else. So critical resources follow commons rules: licenses, caps, reserves, and a dividend.
-
08
Institutions Decay
Institutions decay over generations. So every office has one term, service by lot renews the pool of officials, and the Compact has a scheduled review.
-
09
Small Core, Smart Edges
Systems that scale have a small core and smart edges, like the internet and long-lived commons. Elinor Ostrom found that long-lived commons nest monitoring, enforcement, conflict resolution, and governance in layers. So the Compact is a small protocol, and the same template repeats at each level.